LeadershipTeamBuilder
Team Building

How to Handle Conflict Between Team Members

By Jay Olivo, Founder

Two people on your team are not getting along. Maybe it started with a missed handoff. Maybe it started so long ago that nobody remembers. Now they answer each other in one word, the rest of the team walks on eggshells, and you find yourself planning your day around who sits where.

Here is the short answer. Talk to each person alone first. Then bring them together for one calm, private meeting with ground rules. Keep the talk on the problem, not on each other. Let them build the fix, write it down, and check in a week later. And know your line: some conflicts are not yours to mediate. Those go to HR or your organization's leadership right away.

The rest of this page gives you the steps, a meeting script you can read almost word for word, and what to do the following week.

Why leaders wait, and why that makes it worse

If you have been hoping this will blow over, you are in good company. Stepping into other people's conflict feels awkward. You worry about picking sides. You worry about making it bigger.

But conflict on a team rarely shrinks by itself. Harvard's Division of Continuing Education says conflicts should be dealt with promptly, because unresolved problems can damage the bonds of a team. Reed College's guidance for supervisors adds that, after a conflict, irritation can linger even when things look fine on the surface. Waiting does not make the problem go away. It just makes it quieter, for a while.

First, check the line: is this yours to mediate?

Before you do anything, ask one question. Is this a disagreement between two people, or is it something more serious?

A leader can mediate things like:

Stop, do not mediate, and bring in HR or your organization's leadership if you hear about:

If you lead volunteers or a student group with no HR office, go to the person or board your group answers to. If you are not sure which side of the line you are on, ask for help. That is not weakness. That is good judgment.

Step one: talk to each person alone

Meet with each person privately before you bring them together. Reed College's guidance suggests asking both people the same questions, so you stay fair.

Three questions work well:

  1. "What is going on from your point of view?"
  2. "What do you need to be able to do your job well?"
  3. "What would a good outcome look like for you?"

Mostly, listen. Do not agree or disagree yet. Harvard's guidance warns leaders against "rushing to judgment." You are gathering the story, not ruling on it.

As you listen, notice the difference between what people say they want and why they want it. The Program on Negotiation at Harvard Law School, writing about the classic book Getting to Yes by Roger Fisher and William Ury, calls this focusing on interests, not positions. A position is "I want the morning shift." The interest under it might be "I pick up my kids at 3:00." Positions lock people into corners. Interests leave room to solve the problem.

Step two: meet together, with ground rules

Now bring the two people together. Pick a private, neutral place, not your office with you behind the desk, and not the break room. Harvard's guidance suggests meeting face to face, and avoiding email for working out a conflict. If the team is remote, use a video call.

Set ground rules at the start. Reed College's list is simple: listen to each other, respect different views, do not interrupt, and no personal comments. Keep your own voice calm. People tend to match the temperature in the room, and you are the thermostat.

The meeting script

Use this plan when two team members are in conflict and you have already met with each one alone.

Purpose. Help two people understand each other, agree on a fix, and get back to working together, while keeping each person's dignity.

Time. About 30 minutes. Book 45, just in case.

Group size. Three people: you and the two team members. Nobody else.

Materials. A quiet room or a video call, a page with the ground rules written out, and something to write the agreement on.

Setup. Tell both people ahead of time, in the same words: "I would like the three of us to meet Thursday at 10:00 to sort out how the scheduling is working. It is not a trial. It is a chance to fix it together." Give each person the ground rules before the meeting, so nobody is surprised.

Instructions.

  1. Open (two minutes). "Thank you both for coming. I am not here to decide who is right. I am here to help you two find a way to work together that works for both of you. Here are our ground rules: we listen, we do not interrupt, and we talk about the work, not about each other. Can we agree to that?" Wait for a yes from each person.
  2. Each person speaks (eight minutes). "Sam, will you go first? Tell us what has been hard for you, and what you need. Jordan, your job right now is just to listen. You will get the same time next." Then switch. If someone interrupts, say kindly, "Hold that thought. You are next."
  3. Say it back (four minutes). Ask each person to sum up what they heard the other one say. "Jordan, what did you hear Sam say they need?" This is often the moment the room softens. People rarely feel heard in a fight.
  4. Find common ground (four minutes). "What do you both want here?" Usually it is something like getting the work done on time and not dreading Monday. Write it down where both can see it.
  5. Build options (eight minutes). "What are some ways we could fix this?" Let them do most of the work. Reed College's guidance suggests having people share what they want, what they can commit to, and brainstorm solutions. Add ideas only if they get stuck.
  6. Agree and write it down (four minutes). "So, Sam will post the schedule by Wednesday at noon. Jordan will send swap requests by Tuesday. We will all meet again next Thursday for ten minutes to see how it is going. Does that sound fair to both of you?" Read it back. Get a yes from each person.

If it gets heated. Stop. "Let's take a ten-minute break." Harvard's guidance calls this a cooling-off period. Reed College's guidance says to reconvene when everyone can talk calmly. A break is not failure. Saying the wrong thing in anger is far harder to undo.

Discussion questions to have ready.

A way in for everyone. Some people go quiet when they are upset. Others need time to think before they speak. Offer each person the choice to write down their main points before the meeting and read them aloud, or hand them to you to read. You can also split the meeting in two: share and listen today, build options tomorrow. A person who does not speak English as a first language, or who has a hearing difference, may do better with the agreement written down as well as spoken.

The following week. Hold the ten-minute check-in exactly when you said you would. Ask each person, "What is working? What is not?" If things are better, say so, specifically. If not, adjust the plan together. Reed College's guidance suggests using regular one-on-ones afterward to make sure the old disagreement is not quietly coming back. If the same conflict keeps returning after a fair try, it has crossed the line, and it is time to bring in HR or your leadership.

Keep the talk on the problem

The Program on Negotiation sums up a key idea from Getting to Yes: separate the people from the problem. In a fight, people hear any criticism of their idea as an attack on them. Your job is to keep pulling the talk back to the work.

Pulls toward the personPulls toward the problem
"You two need to grow up.""The schedule keeps changing late, and it is hurting both of you."
"Jordan is just difficult.""What does Jordan need to make the swap work?"
"Who started it?""What would make next week go better?"

The left column asks someone to be guilty. The right column asks both people to be helpful. Only one of those gets the schedule posted on time.

An illustration

This is an illustration, not a real person.

Ana runs a small food pantry with eight volunteers. Two of her regulars, Rick and Lena, have stopped speaking. Rick thinks Lena rearranges his shelves on purpose. Lena thinks Rick's shelves make no sense. The other volunteers have started picking sides by the canned goods.

Ana talks to each one alone. She learns that Lena moves the shelves because families keep asking her where the baby food is, and she wants it easy to find. Rick sets the shelves by delivery date, so the oldest food goes out first and nothing spoils.

At the meeting, each one says back what they heard. Rick says, "So you just want people to find things." Lena says, "And you don't want food going bad." Same goal, different reasons. They agree on one simple fix: shelves grouped by type, oldest items in front, and a small sign for the baby food. Ana checks in the next Saturday. The shelves are fine. Rick and Lena are not best friends, but they are talking. Some of the other volunteers are a little disappointed that the drama is over.

Common mistakes

Where this fits

Conflict is easier to handle on a team where people already feel safe speaking up. If your team has gone quiet, start with How to Build Trust on a Team That Has Stopped Speaking Up. If the issue is one person missing commitments, not two people clashing, How to Hold People Accountable Without Embarrassing Them gives you a private ten-minute talk. And 10-Minute Communication Exercises for Small Teams can help your team practice listening before the next disagreement starts.

Sources

The meeting script, the comparison table, the illustration, and the follow-up week are our additions. This page is general guidance, not legal advice. Follow your organization's own policies.

About the author. Jay Olivo is an author, keynote speaker, coach, and transformational leader, who by profession is certified by Maxwell Leadership and a Certified Professional Maintenance Manager (CPMM). More about Jay.

Want your team to practice this together?

Our Lunch and Learn sessions bring a working session like this one to your team, over lunch, at your place. You bring the people. We bring the leadership.

Ask About a Lunch and Learn